CivicFM
Burbank

· 3 items

Planning Commission, Monday, September 28

On the episode: Media District plan goes to council; film permit fees return in December

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Planning Commission Monday, September 28

3 items

The recording · Agenda

Media District Specific Plan Update: recommendation to the City Council Item 1

Zoning and plansHousing supplyStreets and public works

A public hearing on whether the Planning Commission should recommend that the City Council approve the update to the Media District Specific Plan (Project No. 22-0003509, agenda), certify its final environmental impact report, amend the Burbank2035 General Plan, and amend the zoning code to match. The plan covers the southwestern edge of the city, roughly bounded by Clybourn Avenue, Keystone Street, Oak Street and the Los Angeles River, an area that includes Disney, Warner Bros. and other studios along with offices, shops and housing (agenda). The update sets what uses, heights, densities and parking are allowed there and creates a streamlined, non-discretionary approval path for qualifying housing and small commercial projects. Staff recommended a scaled-back version called the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative, which concentrates growth in the center of the district and limits it to what staff said city utilities can serve. The commission's vote is a recommendation; the City Council makes the final decision. 00:02:19

  • Substitute motion by Mike Van Gorder (Commissioner), seconded by a commissioner: everything in Samantha Wick (Commissioner; Chair)'s motion, plus a recommendation that hotels in the Media District Specific Plan be required to have development agreements. Result: failed, 2-3. No: Samantha Wick (Commissioner; Chair), Paulina Safarian (Commissioner; Vice Chair), Jason Bennett (Commissioner). 01:32:25
  • Samantha Wick (Commissioner; Chair) moved, seconded by a commissioner, to adopt the Planning Commission resolution recommending that the City Council (1) certify the final environmental impact report for the Media District Specific Plan Update, with the resolution's title amended to say it includes the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative as the preferred project, (2) amend the Burbank2035 General Plan consistent with the plan, (3) adopt the amended plan, and (4) adopt an ordinance amending the municipal code to implement it; and to include annual progress reports to the City Council. Result: passed, 5-0. 01:32:35
  • City staff said the Media District plan dates to 1991, has not changed substantially in 35 years, and that very little has been built in that time while housing demand and state housing laws have changed. 00:07:13
  • City staff said the update has been in the works for almost four years and was discussed at more than 40 public events and presentations, with eight rounds of dedicated outreach. 00:08:18
  • City staff said only minor changes were made since the commission last saw the plan: an updated infrastructure chapter, editorial fixes, and edits to reflect the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative as the preferred alternative. 00:08:18
  • City staff described a jobs-housing imbalance in the district, saying about 69,000 people come into it while only 364 both live and work there, which staff said adds to traffic and quality-of-life problems. 00:10:24
  • City staff listed the plan's three goals as development that fits its context, growth oriented to transit, and streamlined housing production. 00:11:26
  • City staff explained that allowed building heights, residential density and commercial intensity step up toward the center of the district and stay lower next to lower-scale residential neighborhoods. 00:13:38
  • City staff said parking rules were aligned with state mandates that generally reduce parking requirements, with minimums kept in some cases because of neighborhood concerns. 00:14:42
  • City staff said the infrastructure chapter does not assume today's water, sewer, power and other systems can handle all future growth, and that new development pays its applicable share of improvements. 00:15:48
  • City staff described the plan's ministerial review path: housing on identified opportunity sites, housing projects of up to 150 units in the area staff described as 87 units per acre, and commercial projects up to 10,000 square feet; other projects stay in discretionary review. 00:16:54
  • City staff explained that the environmental report found some impacts significant and unavoidable, which means the City Council must weigh benefits against impacts and adopt a statement of overriding considerations. 00:21:03
  • City staff said public comments on utilities and infrastructure during the draft environmental review led staff, with Burbank Water and Power and Public Works, to develop the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative. 00:22:07
  • City staff said the alternative concentrates future development in the core of the district and scales back growth there so the city can also accommodate growth in its other specific plan areas. 00:23:09
  • City staff said staff found the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative to be the environmentally superior alternative and recommends it as the preferred project. 00:23:09
  • City staff said growth under the plan could bring the city more revenue than it costs in services at build-out, depending on the type and pace of development, and that the city is looking at an enhanced infrastructure financing district. 00:25:20
  • City staff responded to a union's request for workforce displays by saying staff is working on a separate citywide program for creative signage and off-site advertising that will come forward on its own. 00:52:50
  • City staff disputed the framing that past Burbank hotels needed development agreements because they were hotels, saying those were complex mixed-use projects that did not fit the standard code. 00:52:50
  • City staff said the hotel question went to the City Council, by staff's recollection twice, and the council accepted the conditional use permit requirement and did not direct staff to add a development agreement requirement. 00:53:56
  • City staff answered a complaint about late materials by saying staff reports are customarily published the Thursday before a hearing and the public has another month before the City Council hearing on October 27. 00:54:57
  • City staff said the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative is written into the proposed resolutions and ordinance and into the plan's density and intensity maps. 00:55:58
  • City staff said on wildfire concerns that the environmental law requires studying the project's effect on the environment, not the environment's effect on the project. 00:55:58
  • City staff said the city has issued a notice that it is preparing a separate citywide environmental analysis of the state law SB 79, rather than studying it plan by plan. 00:57:00
  • City staff said the city does not build all utilities for a plan up front but adds them as development is proposed, and that departments' infrastructure planning is expected to be done by the end of December 2029. 00:58:00
  • City staff said individual projects are analyzed for sewer and electrical needs and charged fees when they apply, and the plan's technical studies will be used to update those fees. 00:59:13
  • Mike Van Gorder (Commissioner) asked whether calling the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative the preferred alternative means it is adopted in full or applied selectively. 01:00:06
  • City staff answered that the alternative shows up in the plan through the density and intensity maps, which was the only part of the plan that had to change; the development standards are unchanged. 01:00:39
  • Mike Van Gorder (Commissioner) pointed to the drop in potential housing units from 9,700 under the original proposal to 2,200 under the alternative and asked how that fits the city's state housing targets. 01:01:53
  • City staff said the reduced plan is consistent with the city's housing obligations to the state, and that infrastructure for the larger alternatives could be built but not by the plan's 2035 horizon. 01:02:06
  • City staff added that the housing element's roughly two dozen housing opportunity sites are in the downtown and Golden State plan areas, so Media District units would be on top of those. 01:03:22
  • A commissioner criticized the state environmental law for treating the no-project option as environmentally best, arguing that not building pushes people to live far away and commute long distances. 01:06:37
  • A commissioner said he shares the concern about cutting the number of housing units but understands why staff proposed the alternative. 01:06:37
  • The commission's legal adviser explained that when the no-project option is environmentally superior the law requires naming another alternative, weighing impacts against whether it meets the project's objectives. 01:07:33
  • A commissioner said he disagrees with the report's conclusions and considers the maximum-growth alternative the environmentally friendly one, but accepts the scaled-back alternative as a practical matter. 01:08:36
  • Paulina Safarian (Commissioner; Vice Chair) thanked planning staff for the years of work on the plan and had no questions. 01:09:14
  • A commissioner asked about mixed-use development, saying the district seems well suited to it; staff answered that it is a permitted use in the plan's use table. 01:10:06
  • A commissioner asked staff to clarify what the plan proposes for hotels and whether a development agreement applies. 01:11:39
  • City staff said the plan allows hotels only with a conditional use permit, a discretionary decision by the Planning Commission that can be appealed to the City Council. 01:12:01
  • City staff said the environmental analysis studied up to 400 hotel rooms in the plan area, and anything beyond that would need more environmental review. 01:13:45
  • City staff said, in answer to a question about affordable housing, that projects using the streamlined path must still meet all city rules including affordability rules, and that updates to the density bonus and inclusionary housing rules are coming to the commission. 01:15:18
  • City staff confirmed, in answer to the chair, that the city's public art requirement still applies to development in the district and the mural program continues. 01:16:13
  • A commissioner said he was not happy the scaled-back alternative arrived late in the process but thought it best to approve the plan and move it on. 01:17:22
  • Mike Van Gorder (Commissioner) argued the commission should recommend requiring development agreements for hotels in the district, citing the coming Olympics and a greater need for housing than hotel space. 01:18:04
  • Mike Van Gorder (Commissioner) supported a public commenter's idea of an annual progress report on development and infrastructure capacity. 01:18:04
  • City staff said the plan's implementation program already has the Planning Commission review the capital improvement program, which is then presented to the City Council. 01:19:18
  • The commission chair said she is not against hotel development agreements but would not put the requirement in this one plan, preferring a citywide rule so neighborhoods are treated consistently. 01:19:51
  • Mike Van Gorder (Commissioner) replied that a requirement in this plan would serve as a stopgap until a citywide rule is adopted, at which point it would simply become redundant. 01:20:30
  • A commissioner said she would not recommend development agreements now and would leave it to the City Council to take up if it wishes. 01:21:33
  • The commission chair said she supports the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative and annual progress reports, and that she had expected a study session before the hearing and would have liked one more. 01:21:52
  • The commission's legal adviser pointed out that the commission's own resolution already contains a finding recommending the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative as the recommended project. 01:24:22
  • City staff proposed, at the chair's request for clearer wording, adding to the resolution's title that the environmental report certification includes the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative as the preferred project. 01:26:41

Approval of September 14, 2026 minutes

Routine approval of the minutes of the commission's September 14, 2026 meeting. 01:33:02

  • A commissioner moved to adopt the minutes of the September 14, 2026 Planning Commission meeting as written; a second was stated. Result: passed, 5-0. 01:33:22

City planner comments: when the commission can shape specific plans

Zoning and plans

Closing staff comments turned into an exchange about how and when commissioners can influence large planning documents. Staff said two other specific plan efforts, downtown and Golden State, are still to come, and that study sessions will be scheduled ahead of hearings. No action was taken. 01:33:52

  • City staff thanked the plan's two project managers and Scott Plambaeck (Planning Manager) for their work on the Media District plan. 01:33:58
  • City staff said a follow-up study session on the downtown plan is coming to gather commission comments on the environmental review; it is not yet scheduled but is expected before the end of the year. 01:35:04
  • A commissioner said plans often feel either too early or too late to change by the time the commission sees them, and asked staff to say which parts are still open to change. 01:35:21
  • City staff said plans are most open to change at the study session stage, before the environmental consultant runs the analysis. 01:36:05
  • City staff explained that a major change after environmental review has begun forces the costly analysis to be redone, and said staff will plan study sessions ahead of hearings for the downtown and Golden State plans. 01:36:05

Public comment

  • General oral communications: no speakers in person and no callers.
  • Media District plan hearing: nine people spoke in person and there were no callers. Staff said one email had also been received and sent to commissioners.
  • Four speakers asked that any new hotel in the Media District be required to get a development agreement rather than only a conditional use permit. Three identified themselves as with Unite Here Local 11, a hospitality workers' union (one of them also as a Burbank renter), and one as a homeowner speaking for a local tenants union in support. Their claims: the plan allows roughly 2.4 million additional square feet of commercial development including hotels; seven of Burbank's 18 hotels and nearly two-thirds of its hotel rooms were approved through development agreements; Glendale requires such agreements for new downtown hotels; hotel parking would drop from one space per room to 0.8; and hospitality workers cannot afford to live near their jobs, with one describing a three-hour round-trip commute by transit.
  • One speaker, representing IATSE Local 80, a film and television workers' union that he said has more than 3,000 members and has had its headquarters at 2520 West Olive Avenue for 25 years, asked that the plan and the code amendments allow what the union calls Media District workforce displays: rotating displays on its building of productions its members worked on, through paid promotional agreements with rights holders.
  • One speaker urged the commission not to recommend certifying the environmental report until evacuation and fire safety are studied further, saying the city relies on a 2010-based evacuation map, that streets around the Burbank Toluca Lake neighborhood would be narrowed, and that SB 79 is not addressed; she asked for commitments on firefighting water, evacuation transport for people without cars, coordination with Los Angeles, and neighborhood parking protections.
  • One speaker objected that the hearing materials, which she said were 17 documents totaling thousands of pages, were not public until the Thursday before, and questioned whether sewer and electrical capacity will be ready and who pays. She cited 7.4 miles of sewer upgrades including two miles for the Media District, a forecast peak demand of 421 megawatts against about 69 megawatts of remaining interconnection capacity between 2025 and 2035, and a substation still four to five years away, and said the 2029 deadline in the mitigation plan is too late.
  • One speaker praised the sewer analysis and the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative but asked for analysis of added density from state housing laws, interim milestones instead of a single December 31, 2029 deadline, annual public reports to the City Council on growth and infrastructure capacity, and a clear showing of where the alternative appears in the plan.
  • One speaker said SB 79 undercuts the plan, estimated it would allow at least 57,000 additional housing units citywide, backed the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative but said she could not tell from the packet that it is what is being approved, and asked the commission to hold off until a redline or checklist of the changes is provided.

What's next

  • The Media District Specific Plan Update goes to the City Council; staff said that hearing is on October 27.
  • The commission's recommendation carries two additions made at the meeting: a resolution title stating that the Sustainable Infrastructure Alternative is the preferred project, and annual progress reports to the City Council.
  • Staff said a separate citywide program for creative signage and off-site advertising will come forward as its own item.
  • Staff said the city has issued a notice of preparation for a citywide environmental analysis of SB 79.
  • Staff said the Planning Commission will soon review a development agreement, and will soon see proposed changes to the city's density bonus and inclusionary housing regulations.
  • Staff said city departments' infrastructure planning tied to the plan has an anticipated completion date of the end of December 2029.
  • A follow-up study session on the downtown specific plan's environmental review is expected before the end of the year; no date is set. Staff said it will consider scheduling study sessions ahead of hearings for the downtown and Golden State plans.
  • The commission adjourned to its next meeting on Monday, October 12, 2026 at 6 p.m. in the City Council Chamber.

Write to the Planning Commission before its next meeting: its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error