CivicFM
Burbank

· 3 items

Planning Commission, Monday, October 12

On the episode: Library builder hired, union labor deal required; airport-area hotel advances

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Planning Commission Monday, October 12

3 items

The recording · Agenda

New 420-room dual-brand hotel and parking garage at the Marriott site, 2500 North Hollywood Way Item 1

Development projectsHousing supplyClimate and sustainability

A public hearing on Project No. 16-0003953. The applicant wants to build a new seven-story, 420-room hotel under two brands (Aloft for regular stays and Residence Inn for extended stays) and a separate four-story parking garage. Both would go on surface parking at the existing Marriott hotel and convention center, which would stay open. The site is 11.76 acres bounded by Thornton Avenue, Hollywood Way and Avon Street, across from Hollywood Burbank Airport, and is designated Regional Commercial. The commission was asked to recommend that the City Council approve a Planned Development (site-specific zoning), a ten-year Development Agreement and Development Review. It was also asked to recommend that the Council certify the Final Environmental Impact Report, adopt a mitigation monitoring program and adopt a Statement of Overriding Considerations. That statement is required because, according to staff, three impact areas stay significant and unavoidable even with mitigation: greenhouse gas emissions, construction noise, and the construction noise tied to utility work. The City Council makes the final decision. Speakers were split: union and tenant-group speakers asked for a housing component and stronger emissions and transit measures, while business, labor and hotel-employee speakers backed the project. 00:10:08

▶ Hear it Can workers count on a permanent transit subsidy? · 0:49

  • A commissioner moved to recommend that the City Council approve Project No. 16-0003953 by certifying the Final EIR, adopting the mitigation monitoring program with a Statement of Overriding Considerations and the CEQA findings, and adopting an ordinance approving the Planned Development, Development Agreement and Development Review. The motion amended conditions of approval 16 and 24 to raise the renewable energy share from 10% to 11%, and let the city attorney make editorial clarifications on the project's scope. A commissioner seconded. Result: passed, 5-0. 02:21:39
  • City staff said the commission last heard the project in January 2025, during the public comment period on the draft environmental report 00:12:14
  • City staff described the site as already holding a nine-story, 488-room Marriott hotel, a convention center and surface parking 00:14:14
  • City staff said the new seven-story hotel would have 420 rooms, 203 under the Aloft brand and 217 under Residence Inn, in a building about 83 to 84 feet tall 00:15:15
  • City staff said the new garage would be valet-only, holding 673 cars normally and up to 766 during larger events, with another 285 surface spaces, and that a parking study found the parking sufficient 00:16:18
  • City staff listed the development agreement's community benefits: $30,000 each for future fire and police equipment 00:17:18
  • City staff said the benefits also include money for a neighborhood protection and traffic-calming plan, $80,000 for Burbank Bus operations and $20,000 for Metrolink station maintenance, and put the total value at about $1.1 million 00:18:19
  • City staff said three impact areas remain significant and unavoidable: greenhouse gas emissions, construction noise, and utilities and service systems 00:19:22
  • City staff clarified that the utilities finding is about construction noise from infrastructure work, not a lack of utility capacity 00:19:22
  • City staff said Los Angeles County airport land use commission staff found the project consistent with the county's airport land use plan on August 12, 2026 00:21:27
  • City staff said staff does not expect a significant negative effect on the city's general fund 00:21:27
  • City staff said hearing notices were mailed to owners and occupants within 1,000 feet of the site 00:22:28
  • A guest presenter said the project has been ten years in the making 00:24:17
  • A guest presenter said the building would be 84 feet tall, 33 feet below the maximum allowed on the site 00:25:21
  • A guest presenter claimed it would be the first new all-electric hotel in Burbank 00:26:24
  • A guest presenter said more than 36,000 square feet of solar panels are proposed on the garage roof 00:29:35
  • A guest presenter projected about $2.6 million in hotel tax revenue in the first full year of occupancy, and more than $123 million over thirty years 00:33:05
  • A guest presenter estimated more than $12 million in fees, offsets and community benefit funding, and said the project would upgrade more than 1,500 linear feet of sewer line 00:33:48
  • A guest presenter described a planned partnership with the nonprofit Home Again LA to provide temporary bridge stays for families in its program 00:34:51
  • A guest presenter said a partnership with the Western States Carpenters would ensure the project is built with union labor 00:34:51
  • A guest presenter said the client would invest more than $200 million in the project 00:35:59
  • City staff responded to calls for housing by saying the site is not one of the six or seven housing element opportunity sites in the Golden State area, though housing is not ruled out there 01:16:10
  • City staff said the applicant is a hotel developer whose stated project objective was a hotel 01:18:17
  • City staff defended counting hotel guests in the greenhouse gas service population as a city policy allowed by the municipal code, because guests use energy and water as residents do 01:19:23
  • City staff recommended amending the condition on renewable power from 10% to 11% so it matches the environmental report 01:20:24
  • A guest presenter said the applicant is open to further talks with staff about strengthening the transit subsidy before the Council hearing 01:21:45
  • A guest presenter argued that adding housing would require an entirely different financing structure, which the applicant believes is not possible in today's market 01:22:46
  • A speaker said, as the applicant's land use counsel, that the applicant accepts the change to 11% 01:24:15
  • A speaker criticized the two long opposition letters submitted that day as a disfavored tactic 01:24:15
  • A speaker argued that since hotel guests generate emissions, counting them in the service population keeps the per-person calculation balanced 01:26:19
  • A speaker said the project does not rely on a private 1997 parking agreement with the neighboring office parcel, and that all its parking is on the hotel parcel or off-site for special events 01:28:29
  • A speaker asked whether the community benefits were requested by the city or offered by the applicant 01:30:42
  • City staff said the benefits were city requests, calculated as fair-share contributions for each area, modeled on earlier agreements such as 77 Front Street and Avion 01:32:35
  • A speaker objected to making developers pay for improvements he believes the city should fund, especially when the hotel will also generate tax revenue 01:33:04
  • A speaker explained, as a senior transportation planner, that the transit pass figures come from the city's transportation demand management ordinance and that the applicant's enrollment is voluntary 01:36:06
  • A commissioner said impact fees are standard and paid by everyone, even people building ADUs 01:36:21
  • A commissioner asked whether staff coordinated with the airport land use commission, which was raised in one letter 01:36:57
  • City staff confirmed that with the required sewer upgrades there would be enough capacity for the project 01:38:01
  • City staff said current zoning does not allow housing on the site, but the general plan designation allows a density he believed to be 58 units per acre 01:39:05
  • A commissioner raised a concern that under state no-net-loss law, approving a project with no housing would mean upzoning elsewhere to make up the lost capacity 01:40:55
  • City staff said the underlying density capacity on the site would not be removed, that nearby parcels are proposed for upzoning to about 120 units per acre, and that the general plan projected no new homes in the airport district by 2035 01:41:39
  • A speaker asked how the city's housing projections would lower the citywide three-to-one jobs-to-housing ratio 01:43:29
  • City staff said the housing element plans for more than 10,000 units against a regional allocation of 8,772, and that the three specific plans together are being studied for up to about 16,000 units citywide 01:44:48
  • City staff said the agreement would lock in building rights for up to ten years, though the applicant intends to build within two to three, with impact fees due before building permits 01:46:57
  • City staff described the community benefits as negotiated in exchange for the longer term and the locked-in rules the agreement gives the developer 01:48:32
  • A speaker said a non-CEQA traffic study found no significant intersection impacts except a slight delay increase at one intersection that would occur even without the project, later corrected to Hollywood Way and Victory Boulevard 01:53:18
  • A speaker said a construction management plan required by the conditions would address haul routes and staging 01:52:46
  • A commissioner declined to carry the hearing over to another meeting when the time limit was raised 01:54:57
  • A commissioner asked the applicant for a firm guarantee that the transit subsidy would be a permanent employee benefit 01:55:08
  • A guest presenter declined to commit on the spot, saying the commitment would last in perpetuity, but offered good-faith talks with staff 01:55:36
  • A guest presenter said Home Again LA suggested drafting an MOU with the hotel once construction begins 01:56:25
  • A commissioner noted that earlier public comments almost all asked for housing 01:56:59
  • A guest presenter said the client's preliminary search found no lenders interested in financing a version with housing 01:59:06
  • A guest presenter said the 420-room count came from the existing hotel's data and from market analysis by the developer and Marriott 02:00:24
  • City staff said citywide hotel occupancy is above 70% but not quite 80% 02:02:19
  • City staff said staff hopes to bring the Golden State Specific Plan to the commission in the second quarter of next year, after its draft environmental report is completed in the first quarter 02:02:58
  • A guest presenter said the existing Marriott runs about 81% occupancy and regularly turns away large group bookings 02:03:40
  • A guest presenter said the applicant hopes to break ground about a year after approval, which is too late to open before the Olympics 02:05:13
  • City staff cited a citywide average daily room rate of $184.28 as of August 2026, from the city's economic development staff 02:06:35
  • A speaker argued the development should not be penalized for how guests choose to travel to it, and called city-based greenhouse gas targets flawed 02:07:51
  • A speaker argued it is the landowner's right, not the commission's, to decide to build a hotel 02:08:55
  • A commissioner backed the project, saying financing drives what gets built, and praised the employee benefits and the union labor 02:09:51
  • A commissioner backed the project, citing the city's budget deficit and the projected hotel tax revenue, while urging a stronger transit subsidy 02:11:03
  • A commissioner said he wished the project had included something on housing, such as an in-lieu fee 02:13:44
  • A commissioner suggested earmarking some of the projected hotel tax revenue for housing needs, while saying he supports the project and its union labor 02:15:48
  • A speaker supported the project, saying the housing shortfall can be made up elsewhere in the city 02:16:36
  • City staff pointed to the needed changes to conditions 16 and 24 (raising the renewable energy share from 10% to 11%) and asked permission to clarify the attachments to show the approval covers part of the existing planned development zone 02:17:13

Report to the commission: upcoming October 26 agenda

Under Reports to Commission, staff previewed the next meeting's agenda. 02:21:52

  • A speaker said the October 26 meeting is expected to take up a conditional use permit and development review for a children's play center at 330 North San Fernando Boulevard, and the return of the downtown specific plan policy document for further study 02:22:21

Approval of minutes from September 28, 2026

Routine approval of the minutes from the commission's September 28, 2026 meeting. 02:22:50

  • A speaker moved to adopt the minutes of the September 28, 2026 meeting; the seconder was not identified. Result: passed. 02:23:17

Public comment

  • General oral communications: four speakers, most identifying with the Burbank Tenants Union or Unite Here Local 11. All urged the commission not to recommend the hotel as proposed, or to send it back for a hotel-and-housing alternative. They cited the housing element's nearly three-to-one jobs-to-housing imbalance and the estimate of only 85 jobs from 420 rooms. One pointed to the Front Street project as an example of combining hotel rooms and apartments.
  • Hearing on the hotel: about 18 speakers, 17 in person and one by phone.
  • About six speakers opposed the project as proposed or asked for changes. Most were affiliated with Unite Here Local 11, including an attorney for the union. They argued the environmental report understates greenhouse gas emissions by counting 588 hotel guests in the service population. They also said it wrongly rejects a hotel-and-housing alternative and defers trip-reduction mitigation without monitoring. They criticized the transit subsidy as covering only 75% of a monthly pass, on request, for at most 20% of employees (about 17 workers), and as able to end after a one-week survey. They also said the conditions require less solar and a lower green-building tier than the report assumes. They asked for fully paid transit passes, guest transit incentives, ongoing monitoring, and a recirculated analysis.
  • About 12 speakers supported the project. They included three Western States Regional Council of Carpenters representatives, who cited union jobs and apprenticeships; the Burbank Chamber of Commerce's chair and its CEO, who cited tourism, hotel tax revenue and the convention center losing large events for lack of rooms; three current hotel employees, who described their employer as treating them like family; and entertainment-industry workers and a caller, who said visiting productions need more lodging. The caller also argued the site is better suited to commercial use than housing.
  • Written comment: staff said letters came in with the agenda packet, in a supplemental, and in person that night. The applicant's counsel described two long opposition letters submitted that day, one from a law firm for Unite Here and one written on behalf of the neighboring office building's owner, which raised a private parking agreement and the airport land use commission.

What's next

  • The City Council will make the final decision on the hotel project and its environmental report. No hearing date was given.
  • The applicant said it would continue talks with staff about strengthening the employee transit subsidy between the commission and Council hearings.
  • The applicant said it would draft an MOU with Home Again LA once the hotel is under construction.
  • The city attorney was allowed to make editorial clarifications to the resolution and ordinance on the project's scope, as part of the existing planned development zone.
  • The Golden State Specific Plan's draft EIR is targeted for the first quarter of next year, with a commission recommendation hearing hoped for in the second quarter.
  • The October 26, 2026 commission meeting is expected to take up a conditional use permit and development review for a children's play center at 330 North San Fernando Boulevard, and the return of the downtown specific plan policy document.
  • The applicant expects to break ground about a year after approval.

Write to the Planning Commission before its next meeting: its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error